Hayden Panettiere – I just feel like I don’t like the combination of the jacket with the leather pants. If her top were simple, it would work better. On a scale of 1-5 (1-worst – 5 best) -3

Paris Hilton – Why does the girl have to look so rough?! 1.8

Nicky Hilton – 3

Whitney Port – No to the jacket that looks weird on you, No to your hair, No to trying to make those boots happen. – 1.5

Clearly, it was a rough day so I’m more harsh than usual…

Garcelle Beauvais-Nilon – 4

Maggie Grace – 4

Lily Collins – It’s very daring and not very many people can pull it off except for her. 4.5

Downtown Julie Brown – 1/2 GET OFF the red carpet please. You just made this so unclassy.

Stacey Dash – in French Connection. 5 – did I mention she’s 43?

Cat Deeley – meh 3

MIA being awesome. I just don’t judge her outfits

Model Mini Anden – 4.5 I love this dress, her hair should have been left down for this one.

Jimmy Choo founder Tamara Mellon – 4 wearing her own design

Sasha Alexander – 3.8 I like the cut out of this dress.

Olivia Wilde – 3? Does anyone else feel like this is slightly overwhelming on her?

Rashida Jones – 5. Not exhaustive, not too much. Nice shoes. Jacket worn right.