Rihanna in Marchesa – 2.8 This looks like a crumpled up doily.
Fergie in Armani Prive – 3. This is how I always judge her looks.
Carrie Underwood in Theia – I really love this look. Sometimes I get tired of the whole Grecian look, but then again I love the one-shouldered dress. AND THOSE SHOES! – 4.5
Alicia Keys in Giorgio Armani – The dress is fantastic. And the shoes are okay. The jewelry is a bit much and the hair can go… This look had potential to be a 5, but because of everything else I’m just going to give it a 3.
Leona Lewis in Vivienne Westwood – 2 Vivienne Westwood is great, sure. I’d love to see Leona try some other designers now too. NO to those boots.
Shakira in Versace. 5! I really love this dress. I don’t really like the shoes… but my love for the dress overrules. Shakira looks really great in this dress. It was perfect for her.
Demi Lovato in Jenny Packham – 3.5. I like that Demi went very natural for this look everything from her shoes, to her dress color, to her makeup. It washes her out a little bit, but it’s nice to see her clean up and not look so out there. The dress is okay. The neckline is too much for me.
Selena Gomez in Talbot Runhof. 4. This is a very age-appropriate dress for her. She looks cute!
Kelly Clarkson. 1.5. oh noooo Kelly 🙁 this dress is so unflattering and is a bejeweled disaster ahh
Kristen Bell in Christian Cota – 4. She looks great! You don’t see a dress like that everyday. Kristen made a midriff showing dress classy instead of trashy.
Nicole Kidman in Balenciaga. I don’t care if it’s Balenciaga…this is so wrong. 1
Edyta Sliwinska – Why so many cutouts? This brings me back to terrible memories of Blake Lively’s dangerous slit dress. 2
Kayle Ewell – This dress is AMAZING! This is something I would wear! 5!
Shaun Robinson. It’s nice. It’s safe. 3
Paula Abdul cleaned up nicely. Usually her red carpet outfits suck really hard, but this is actually nice. I usually don’t like the fish tail either especially when Beyonce has a dress with one, but this is something I wouldn’t mind looking at. 4
Jennifer Lopez in Gucci. 3 Meh Nicky Hilton could probably wear this dress a lot better than you.